Skip Nav

Daisy Miller a Hero Essay

From the SparkNotes Blog

❶James creates ambiguity around Daisy as an insightful glimpse into the harsh social expectations of the day. Only the most shiveringly sensitive of our shoddy population are bold enough to deny the truth of this wonderful little sketch.


How to cite this page
Navigate Guide
Critical Evaluation

The fact that he has done so with a touch of marvelous delicacy and truth, that he has produced not so much a picture as a photograph, is held by many to be an aggravating circumstance. Only the most shiveringly sensitive of our shoddy population are bold enough to deny the truth of this wonderful little sketch. To those best acquainted with Mr.

James's manner and I believe I have read every word he has printed Daisy Miller was positively startling in its straightforward simplicity and what I can only call authenticity.

It could not have been written—I am almost ready to say it cannot be appreciated—except by one who has lived so long abroad as to be able to look at his own people with the eyes of a foreigner. All poor Daisy's crimes are purely conventional. She is innocent and good at heart, susceptible of praise and blame; she does not wish even to surprise, much less outrage, the stiffest of her censors. In short, the things she does with such dire effect at Vevay and at Rome would never for an instant be remarked or criticised in Schenectady.

They would provoke no comment in Buffalo or Cleveland; they would be a matter of course in Richmond and Louisville. One of the most successful touches in the story is that where Daisy, astonished at being cut by American ladies, honestly avows her disbelief in their disapproval. In his introduction, Henry James says that Daisy Miller originated in an anecdote about a young American girl which he heard in Rome in the autumn of However, two travel sketches which he wrote several years earlier help to explain the development of the story.

In James spent three months in Switzerland and six months in Rome, the two places which form the setting for Daisy Miller. In "Swiss Notes," contributed to the Nation for Sept.

To support his own observation of the highly artificial character of life in Geneva, he refers to a novel by Cherbuliez: He had already identified this country as a place where one could become the victim of rigid The events in James's early success, Daisy Miller , might seem to be naturally suited to tragic or strongly pathetic effects. An innocent young American girl tours Europe, behaving in the open, casual, uncircumspect way that comes naturally to her.

Her free ways with men are misinterpreted by the sophisticated, Europeanized Americans she meets. She is gradually ostracized, forced more and more into the company of Europeans. The Conquest of London, J. Lippincott Company, , pp. I have got back to work with great zest after my autumnal loafings, and mean to do some this year which will make a mark.

I am, as you suppose, weary of writing articles about places, and mere potboilers of all kinds; but shall First, he, as the dean of American critics, certified her important position in both the Jamesian canon and in the literary world at large. Second, he affirmed by both precept and example that she would be understood best not as an isolated phenomenon but as a part of a literary Oscar Cargill's definition of James' "international novel" indicates how close James came in so many of his novels to presenting the psycho-physical experience we now refer to as culture shock.

As James Gargano pointed out in his excellent article, "Daisy Miller: An Abortive Quest for Innocence," critical attention has concentrated obsessively on the heroine of James's most popular nouvelle and has consequently ignored the fact that its central character is, in fact, Frederick Winterbourne [ South Atlantic Quarterly, Winter, ].

From the time of John Foster Kirk's denunciation of Any overview of the past century's critical responses to Daisy Miller reveals a radical shift in readers' sympathies with its characters. The genteel American audience of James's day was outraged and insulted by Daisy's liberated behavior, but modern sensibilities identify Winterbourne as the principal offender against human decency.

They accuse him of being everything from an Finally, the best known and perennial favorite among James's early stories is Daisy Miller , a nouvelle that like "Madame de Mauves" employs third-person narration focused on a viewpoint character of "register. First, its notoriety and popularity made James for a brief moment in his career a popular writer There is only one way to improve ourselves, and that is by some of us setting an example which the others may pick up and imitate till the new fashion spreads from east to west.

Some of us are in more favorable positions than others to set new fashions. Some of us are more striking personally, and imitable, so to speak. But no living person is sunk so low as not to be imitated by somebody. Pollak, Cambridge University Press, , pp. Daisy has grown up in an exclusive world which has, to an extent, excluded her from communicating with everyone acceptably, but which has allowed her to be stylish and enjoy the fashions of Paris that she loves.

The ambiguous meaning of this exchange with Winterbourne serves to set Daisy apart from the small minded Mrs. Costello who refuses a meeting with her. This fact does not upset Daisy in the least; she actually seems to admire the fact that Mrs.

Daisy does enjoy the company of gentlemen; however, it is not intended to perturb either her family or her friends. She acts from impulse and a heartfelt desire to absorb the beauty of the world around her.

The word intimate could indicate some type of sexual connection, but for Daisy, the concept of intimacy conjures a different connotation, one of a warm friendship from the innermost reaches of the mind and heart.

Giovanelli escorts her to the places that she wants to visit: He plays the piano beautifully and is expressive, a contrast to the closed, stiff mind of Winterbourne. Giovanelli is the conduit through which Daisy may explore the world. Winterbourne is jealous of the possibility that Giovanelli might ever be lucky enough to find himself married to someone like Daisy and be part of her high social level.

Winterbourne spends more time analyzing the behavior of Daisy than living his own life or enjoying life with her. He is an outsider, compelled by a desire to peek into her mind and world, offer advice, make generalized statements and hold his own emotions in check. Daisy may have assumed the name of a delicate flower, but she is far from a wilting bloom. Her open and spirited personality is highlighted on the night of her final adventure at the Colosseum.

Regardless of his assessment, he approaches her in her last moment of independent glory. Her determination to view the Colosseum in moonlight is a final testament to her uncontrollable nature and instinct. Winterbourne spends a great deal of time admonishing both Daisy and Mr. Giovanelli for his interpretation of their time alone together, but he chooses to either forget about his insistence upon being alone with Daisy at the castle, or to forgive himself for those actions.

Either way, he represents the double standard that exists in his world or he embodies it. In the same moment he declares her to be the most innocent person he that he has ever encountered. Hypocrisy flows around the protagonists in Daisy Miller and it is their interpretation of what is publically accepted behavior that drives the themes of the novella.

Daisy operates outside accepted protocols. Miller is a stagnant character, usually ill and unable to accompany her on her endeavors into the world. Their intentions may not be honorable, but this fact is insignificant to Daisy, men do not dictate to her, she dictates to them. Her actions are scrutinized by women like Mrs. This soiled reputation flows over conventional lines, and could potentially bring ruin and rumble to the entire social strata in which these small minds operate.

It is only at the very last moment in the story, when Daisy is dead, that he declares her innocence to be fact. It is too late for Daisy at this point. She spends her life clinging to an almost childlike demeanor without inhibition.

Daisy is simply too passionate and spirited for her time and place.

Study Questions

Main Topics

Privacy Policy

Free Daisy Miller papers, essays, and research papers.

Privacy FAQs

Henry James’s Daisy Miller, which explores the social expectations placed upon Americans traveling in Europe, reveals the hypocrisy inherent in judging other people. Throughout the novella, the.

About Our Ads

Daisy Miller essays are academic essays for citation. These papers were written primarily by students and provide critical analysis of Daisy Miller by Henry James. Free Essay: The controversial short story Daisy Miller: A Study, written by Henry James, depicts a story of a young European man named Winterbourne trying to.

Cookie Info

Daisy Miller in wonderland After read Daisy Miller Recently I read the novel daisy miller which written by Henry James. It’s a short novel but the vocabularies are difficult to me, so after I found the movie and saw it with Xueqin. Alexander Jack Papetsas AP Senior English Assignment: James’ use of Ambiguity in Daisy Miller and theme Ambiguity Conveys Theme in James’ Daisy Miller In the novella, Daisy Miller by Henry James, the complexities of social conventions, gender stereotyping and conformity are exposed through the actions and words of the protagonists. Daisy Miller is the young [ ].